talk.kiezburn.org
Sun 19 Jan 2020 1:43PM

Consensual Do-ocracy - short definition

RH Richard Hodkinson Public Seen by 128

Kiez Burn is co-created through the principle of Consensual Do-ocracy:

You are able to make any decision regarding Kiez Burn, if

  • you have sought advice from experts on the subject and the people who will be affected by your decision,

  • you are willing to take responsibility for the actions & consequences coming from the decision or have the support needed to make it happen,

  • you got consent from other event realizers that are affected by your decision.

Introduction

Through this principle and its methods, we attempt to live the Kiez Burn principles. It is not easy. We fuck up, we make mistakes, we learn and we improve. We are not here to make a perfect burn with perfect individuals. We are here to grow, together.

This short definition is usually sufficient in enabling anyone to take on responsibility. Hundreds of decisions are taken at Kiez Burn. Examples include:

  • How to set up an efficient electrical power grid

  • Designing a shift schedule for rangers or welfare leads

  • How to make a fun & informative greeting experience at the gate

These decisions do not affect that many people and are usually taken by people who are already experts on a particular subject. For bigger decisions, please use the advice process.

Why we do this

The principle of consensual do-ocracy means the power to decide on an idea, should be with those who carry out the idea (a.k.a. realizers). Sufficient energy should be put into (1) exploring if this idea will truly benefit Kiez Burn as a whole, and (2) making sure this idea is consented to by other Kiez Burn leaders who would be affected by a decision on this idea.

By learning more about the topic and connecting with people that are dependent on a decision of the idea, they become the best qualified in the community to take on or take over a responsibility. They become leaders within temporary hierarchies based on the thinking that power should flow to those who need it, in order to carry out ideas.

Given the above, anyone should be able to propose an idea, improve on it, gather consent and then decide to carry it out. They are now responsible for the actions & consequences coming from this proposal or/and have the support needed to make this proposal happen & deal with the (unintended) consequences.

  • Usually, the short definition of consensual do-ocracy is sufficient to guide people from idea to decision. 

  • For bigger decisions, we found we need more structure, which is given by the advice process

  • In case of strong disagreement:

    • The conflict escalation process allows for individuals to stop a decision by making sure leaders listen to advice

    • A meeting can be called so to solve bigger disagreements between groups of people

Consent is defined here as “not having significant objections (to a certain proposal)”. If an affected person cannot accept the proposed action, they state their objections with reasons that can be understood by the others. The responsibility of all is to listen with the intent to understand and adapt the proposal to minimize possible risks. Consensing does not require agreement, affirmation or even preference.  Consent is reached by choosing the proposal with the least objections. The lowest level of objection — resistance — results in the highest acceptance. (source)

DU

Alina, also known as Universe Fri 24 Jan 2020 2:49PM

I see. I propose that consensual do-ocracy must be well understood before engaging in it. I see that a lot of documentation on Talk is being created and that is super helpful. However, my guesstimate is that only 5% of KiezBurn population are aware of the effort, the idea, how it actually works, what it means for the community. We are not ready for the levels of participation you would expect from complete do-ocracy just yet. The community is not informed and not ready to understand the need to step up (as far as I can see from Talk/FB - online stuff) I see the beginning of the spread and assimilation of the new vision for the self-organising KiezBurn as an active and relentless push out of the Board and to the hippies. If the main "population" remains uninformed, the same small committee of committed hippies will keep doing the big chunk of the work.

W

walto Fri 24 Jan 2020 2:06AM

The threads in this group evolved from a workshop that was organized by board members. At the same time, it is also the product of the people that actually did it, in this case Richard.

More definitely could be more. What do you feel could help achieve the goals of consensual do-ocracy more?

DU

Alina, also known as Universe Thu 23 Jan 2020 5:45PM

For me this sounds like an important Baustelle that need guidance by/from the Board. Values, visions and principles need a focused lead committee, that for me is the Board. I do not think we can just get away with building something with a bunch of well-meaning hippies on a Loomio thread. Consensual Do-ocracy needs to have a VISION and a FRAMEWORK and then some TOOLS of community empowerment in place first.

W

walto Mon 27 Jan 2020 7:32PM

I would advise a Talk thread, but would leave the decision up to you.

CY

CJ Yetman Mon 27 Jan 2020 7:22PM

In what format?

W

walto Mon 27 Jan 2020 6:16PM

@CJ Yetman would you possibly volunteer for drafting the Talk proposal template? https://realities.kiezburn.org/d606256a-0395-4d72-8de5-c5a7c9de8a67/e6b87482-6eae-4e7a-b4f0-e0296d0ff7ff

Template for agenda & template for presentations for meetings are done.

W

walto Fri 24 Jan 2020 5:40PM

Another idea: provide template for agenda + presentation for meetings.

W

walto Tue 21 Jan 2020 8:11PM

actually, here is a thread where we used the proposal formatting: https://talk.kiezburn.org/d/hsnfYjZB/dream-token-redistribution-for-dreams-not-reaching-minimum-from-orientation-to-finalization

Maybe in the new Loomio 2.0 we can work with templates? @tobias wdyt?

W

walto Tue 21 Jan 2020 7:53PM

Good point! There is actually a template that Borderland uses, that could be useful for us as well. It is documented here: https://talk.kiezburn.org/d/IjSQFmf0/the-advice-process

We could make it into a thread template... would be great :)

CY

CJ Yetman Mon 20 Jan 2020 8:17PM

I would love to see a template for making a proposal that guides people to put down all the relevant information that others need to assess the proposal and give important feedback.

Load More