talk.kiezburn.org
August 25th, 2021 07:01

[Open discussion] On popularity, organic growth, virgins, and inclusivity

Saskia
Saskia Public Seen by 145

I would like to start an open discussion inviting everybody with an opinion on the topic to make theirs heard.

Why? Because I am interested if I am alone with my perception and I wonder what other people think. I am particularly interested in the opinions of people who have observed the growth of other burn events (e.g. borderland) - are there parallels? Also, I think that direct impressions after the event might help KORG 2022 to make informed decisions.

So: What are your impressions on the development and public reception of Kiez Burn?

My personal impression is that Kiez Burn is gaining in popularity. This year I overheard people talking about Kiez Burn on the floors of H13, Knüppel, and other locations. We even got the 'look, there is a significant event'-treatment by the police! :O

I think we cannot act as if we were not an event around Berlin. This means that we offer a 5 day event for a 80 euro price tag (+ very attractive 'burner' tag) when around us there are events where one weekend costs 200 (excl. drinks and food and travel). Sure, they have the bigger line up - but I get the impression that bigger names from Berlin and around the world will join camps and make Kiez Burn more popular in the future.

We had a big percentage of virgins, as it seems. And while the party mood and also the general behavior seemed to be top game this year (with almost no incidents etc.) and the event ran like a smooth sailing ship... there were some aspects that were also very un-burnery, most noticeably the MOOP situation. Maybe I am also unfair when I blame certain issues on virgins...

I wonder if a return to more directed tickets / a cap on free campers and educational approaches for virigins may help with organic and healthy growth?




Kris

Kris August 25th, 2021 09:06

This is a common refrain from every burn. It certainly helps to have a remote site that tries to kill you, but you hear it from Burning Man as well.

My biggest surprise with Kiez burn is that it's only five days, having more people come early and experience the city being built and coming to life helps people feel ownership and being part of something special. Like you're not showing up to a pre-built event where things are curated for you. Your brain should be fully washed before the weekend rolls around.

I think being associated with Berlin can be a big strength, the activist and club scene here works hard to foster a good and respectful community. And being able to attend an event with people who have some kind of cool in the default can entice people to participate more.

Regarding directed tickets I'd toot my own horn and suggest experimenting with what we halfway did for Borderland in 2019 with replicating directed tickets. We'd have an allotment of tickets that replicate, that is if you buy one you get two invitations to give away, until they run out. That way established camps can be directed only a couple of replicating tickets, and then give them out first to their established members and then to their friends. This follows how burns usually recruit - you meet someone who's been there. Unlike directed tickets it's little work for the orga to decide who's "deserving", but still gives a way to sanction camps that for instance MOOP a lot.

In my experience most virgins do a lot fit in and often behave better than old-timers, but of course some people just don't know where they are.

So I suggest,

  • Have a 7-8 day event

  • Close the gate before the weekend

  • Replicating tickets

I can really recommend The Scene That Became Cities for more perspectives on this, I have a copy you can borrow.

K

Kitt August 25th, 2021 11:56

EDIT TO ADD - just want to add --> I would really like to connect with some of the orga/lead role people at burns like Burning Nest and Nowhere or the other UK regionals to learn from them how they expanded and dealt with introducing the culture to a newer scene years ago... I think there's interesting intersections and differences in the growth and community of KB and that's my biggest/most important contribution to this thread. Diversifying the burner cultures that are influencing this one.

I meet a lot of people who would like to join the burn, but have no idea of how to initiate them except one-by-one... as I think the culture of KB is still developing and evolving and finding its own character, I think it's important to be active in 'recruitment' but it's not everyone's jam to do that. It would be nice if there were events that brought some of the principles of the burn were visible and accessible to new burners (decom?) that inspired people how to engage with the principles themselves. I could also see a cute little 'what is a burn/burner?' video produced by Berlin burners to try and explain some of the culture. Some people get inspired by watching videos of Black Rock and wanting to bring it here, some people get inspired by doing. These are just brainstorming ideas.

I also have never been to the burner embassy, full disclosure, which might perform some of these functions.

I think it's also key to recognise that many people in Berlin are artists/performers themselves, so gifting some aspect of their work is a little harder for newbies to understand and accept, and when people interact with art grants for their day-to-day job it becomes a bit competitive at times to try and get funding, which can also be a highly emotionally charged issue. Some of the smaller art projects that received funding were proposed by some of the busier and more involved burners, who in some cases were not able to actualise that art to completion on site. I have a proposal to help with this below...

I think you're right, the Berlin burner scene is highly influenced by the party aspect of Berlin... I see the biggest influences as the city's techno/party culture, the castle burn (which I have never been to, but my perception is that it's a fancy expensive burner party weekend aka 'not for me',) and people who have the resources to have been to the big burn in Nevada, sometimes multiple times. Also The Borderland, which I have also never been to ;) My biggest bias is that my first burns were Nowhere (Spain) and Burning Nest (which is in the UK) so I am always leaning towards bring more of the small, heartfelt art camp vibe... and while the burn seemed 'incident free' I think there is a lot of uphill challenge and behind the scenes work to bring an actualised theme camp to its full potential.

To bring up a difficult subject again... art grants. I would love to see more micro art grants (100-150euros) given in full to small interactive art projects. Things like the radio station or interactive sculptures would have been really nice to encounter, and I think would inspire more people to build and co-create. There's no perfect way to handle grants and each burn does it differently, but this is where the identity of KB could really start to emerge. (I would also LOVE to see some cultural development aspect added to art grants like nest/nowhere who specifically have grants directed towards social issues and sustainability.... )

I would love to see a longer event, but longer than 7 days is not necessary IMO. I'm not sure we have the site for it yet.

I would love to see more theme camps, more small art, more participation... and stronger theme camp identities, and that will draw in the right crowd of people, and activate people to become burners who hold the principles closer in mind.

K

Kitt August 25th, 2021 12:06

Hiya, while some of this is interesting, I am kind of opposed to the replicating ticket situation... while I think established theme camps specifically could almost always use more directed ticket access (this IMO drives participation and co-creation) this would only drive the burn to become culturally more monolithic and same-same... I think we should ponder how to increase the diversity of burners... and I think that takes education and events away from the core burn. I would also not know how to implement this replicating ticket situation. People cannot be entirely self reliant if they rely on a 'who they know' situation to get a ticket.

Kris

Kris August 25th, 2021 12:38

If you want to improve diversity through sales you'd have to do some sort of affirmative action, staying with first come first served obviously won't improve that. I'd very much support such initiatives, but it's not related to this.

Also note that I said an allotment, not every ticket.

Kris

Kris August 25th, 2021 12:55

Uh, I want to add two points to that:

  • I don't think the kieze are monocultures, and we should rely on (and encourage them) to create diverse camps. My friends don't all look like me, live the same life as me, or went to the same school as me, that is what's attractive about burns.

  • The 10 principles are not just headings, they come with text. Radical Self-Reliance states: "Burning Man encourages the individual to discover, exercise and rely on their inner resources". It does not mean "I only have to talk to a computer to get a ticket", it does mean "You're not here for a boutique experience".

K

Kitt August 25th, 2021 14:22

Totally appreciate your responses here, I am not trying to be oppositional just nudge into some things a bit deeper during this conversation :) We have 11 principles at KB by the way ;) It's hard to know how to initiate newbies, there are some people I have brought into the community by saying 'I will answer any question but you must get your own ticket and your own camp' because sometimes that is a helpful way to lose a few people who find it 'too hard' and yet other people I would rather initiate in an entirely different fashion... I don't think there's a one-size-fits-all approach to bringing in new people. Some people self-discover burner culture and might find themselves excluded if it is a referral-tree replicating ticket system, or might find themselves on the outside of the social groups that bring large groups to the burn, and I don't want to dis-include those folks I guess :).

Kris

Kris August 25th, 2021 14:33

We can totally also sell first come first serve tickets, so there's no contradiction there. Like it was suggested in planning we can do two rounds and have an early round in January for the hardcore that then can commit lots of their time, knowing that they will get in.

CJ Yetman

CJ Yetman August 25th, 2021 15:02

Just for context… as far as I understand (as a Korg member for the last 2 KBs and significantly involved in other ways), the first-come-first-serve ticket sale was 100% driven by the short time frame, which was 100% driven by the covid situation. I hope / don’t believe that there is any organizational need or desire to ever do that again.

RMD

RMD August 26th, 2021 10:14

Take my view with a grain of virginity:
1) I'd be very keen to have more "obligations" to contribute/participate, in order to counteract the "consumerist" attitude
I wouldn't find it too radical to suggest that ALL freecampers should be required to do orga shifts or dreams or something else.
And likewise for camps (not that I've seen any boring camps!)
[guess this is essentially directed tickets?]


2) [most likely stupid idea but] Another way to increase involvement during the event could be to have people (e.g.: rangers) to go around camps, talk about what's needed, recruit some volunteers on the spot, etc.
This would involve communication between those who spot issues and the intermediaries - like a needs board of sorts - in exchange for "get out of spanking free" cards or so
/////
Another version would be "production meetings" with all camps/freecamper reps also during the event [could also increase the visibility of the orga work needed and a bit more contagious appreciation]

3) More rituals. The effigy thing was the only point where everyone got together and a sense of common narrative between all camps was attempted - so more of that helps? (of course, it should not be boring and too much, etc)

(Also always great opportunities to "demand" participation from camps/freecampers to contribute something to the ceremony)

I'd prefer if we don't have to cause a major fire hazard just for a chance of bringing people together, but whatever.

4) "Banning" people from flying in probably would improve everything as well.

Inclusion arguments are bullshit as flying by itself is exclusionary - and it is a climate crisis we're in, so essentially you're excluding the next people to be killed by wildfires, floods, etc. Furthermore, this HAS to be a "slow" event in order for it to function as intended. Flying in, consuming and flying out is exactly the type of attitude that doesn't make sense here.

Of course, "how" you ban people from flying is a bit of an illusion (much like trying to control freecampers and so on), but it would already make a difference just by stating it - as well as during ticket buying having fun stuff like a dropdown choice of transport and then being refused if you choose flying (or failing questions regarding to the 11 principles), etc.

CJ Yetman

CJ Yetman August 26th, 2021 11:21

I think there's a misperception that many to all of these problems are related to virgins, free campers, and other people who are not well educated on the principles etc. While that may be the case to some degree, I don't believe that's the driving force behind all the terrible behavior and anti-social stuff we saw at KB this year. Massive LNT problems, graffiti all over the place, pervasive Korg/"production"-will-take-care-of-it attitudes, etc... many of this was coming from veteran burners, veteran KB-ers, people who damn well know the principles and their meaning, but apparently just don't give a shit.

Lise

Lise August 26th, 2021 14:39

Yes to what @Kitt said. Perspective of someone who was "on the outside": I was a virgin this year. I had heard about KB from several people, but they were not close friends who would have directed me a ticket, so the open ticket sale was my "way in". If the only way to get a ticket was by replicating/directed ticketing, that would feel quite elitist and radically exclusive for self-discovering people like me.

Lise

Lise August 26th, 2021 14:52

Yes to educational approaches for virgins! Speaking from the perspective of a virgin: It's easy to find and read the principles, but it took a LOT of reading on Talk to figure out how they are translated into action. Especially for virgins who self-discover (to use Kitt's words) rather than being introduced to KB by a mentor friend, a "How to burn"/"KB 101" would be very helpful to understand not only how to behave but also how to become more involved.

Edit to add two more thoughts:

1) If it was even clearer for first-timers who are unfamiliar with the principles and the "How to burn" that KB requires actual work before, during and after (by translating the principles into blunt "what it actually means" words), that might already help with healthy self-selection?

For example, when buying the ticket, instead of general terms and conditions, you would have to accept "I have read and understood that I will help build the whole thing with my own hands, that I will have to think of and bring everything that I need to survive from food to extension cords, that I will clean festival toilets, and that I will pick up and collect every scrap of waste and take it with me when leaving".

2) The sooner virgins and people who are not part of an established camp get an "onboarding" and come into the process, the more time to learn and get familiar and get engaged (meaning they shouldn't get tickets late in the process when preparations are already in full swing)

And a question: I was also baffled by several "Just learned about this event, now on a plane to Germany" posts on fb in the days before KB. I also remember that many people flew from Berlin to Capetown and back within a week for Africa Burn in 2019. I would also love to participate in a different burn at some point which would involve traveling and I don't categorically blame people for flying, but it just seems so incompatible with LPT efforts in this context. How do you deal with this issue in the burner community?

Vlad

Vlad August 26th, 2021 15:08

Direct ticket allocation for theme camps + lottery for the rest would probably work better than first come first served.

Vlad

Vlad August 26th, 2021 17:03

Once I had a very interesting conversation: our kitchen and fridge were adjustement to the jam tent. I was on a way to playa and tried to grab a drink from the fridge. In this very moment a guy came buy, pushed an empty beer bottle into my hand and said: "I would like a refill". after that we had a very long and beautiful conversation cause I really wanted to know how refill system is organized at kiez burn. Sometimes ppl also were helping themselves with drinks, god I dont want to know what was happening when I was not around. The same happened with the food as well. MOOP was a similar experience to Underworld on a smaller scale of course, Sunday night i gathered quite a lot of little shitty pieces of plastic from cigarete and other packages all around our tent.

I guess the only way to fix it is to advertise in big letters during the ticket sales:

At this event there is no food, no drinks, no music, no drugs, no art, no fun unless you bring it with you, you can't buy or sell anything!

This might stop quite some ppl from buying a random ticket.

But on the other hand we all were there, try to get a drink in burning man if you are on the other side of the playa from your base and you dont know anybody here, this is where ppl really learn to beg like the need it.

Concerning event growth, probably the best example is burning man itself, or maybe borderland. As far as I can feel burning events experience a change of generations with all good and bad things coming with it. And communication is a key to making burners understand it. And it mght be not enough just to have 10 principles, cause in reality they are very fuzzy and dont really explain the situation.

It is an interesting idea with locking the gates on wednesday, but I am not sure a very practical one, ppl might be late for some many reasons (like bahn strike this year, or work, or family) nevertheless they can still be able to contribute.

Tickets in my opinion should be distributed through camps (maybe at least 50%) and the rest in a weighted lottery, were ppl promising bring art-workshops etc have a higher probabilty to win.


K

Kitt August 26th, 2021 18:05

I am thumbs down on lottery, have 2 or more rounds of planned sales that committed people need to plan to get. (Then perhaps use the STEP system like Nowhere so that people can be offered any refunded tickets down a waiting list.) Going to a burn (IMO) shouldn't be a game of chance, and shouldn't feel exclusive in that way, it should yield results for people who plan and who are committed.

(This is not necessarily the same for other burner events or even other burns, but lotteries don't help with KB's principles of community or inclusion in my opinion... I personally prefer the sales + waiting list approach, but know this might be a hassle/transition to manage.)

Kris

Kris August 26th, 2021 21:41

Having run a few lotteries, I think it's messy and not a very good process. It ends up being a gimmick and not much fairer than first come first served (FCFS).

I've also ran STEP and it's OK to eliminate the FB group selfie begging, but doesn't do much more. We had very little to no scalping to begin with according to the data we collected.

Having a quota of FCFS is important, I agree.

Kris

Kris August 26th, 2021 21:48

I agree with most of this, but I don't think people's "value" should be determined in terms of what they materially bring or put into as an effort. If people are needed because they have skills to realize something, absolutely we should liberally direct to them, but not some kind of weighted lottery based on how much you promise up front. Magic is often spontaneous.

Wednesday is way too early to close gate, but maybe mid Friday? Maybe a special ticket you have to apply for weekend warriors that have a good reason?

Kris

Kris August 26th, 2021 22:01

The large contingent of people that fly halfway around the world for this, often with a radically different conception of what "burning" means than the euroburners, does occasionally disturb me. Then again I fly halfway around the world to go to Burning Man, and often have a radically different conception of "burning" from the US-burners. It does irk me when people who can afford to fly here complain about the price of a camp though, or excuse themselves from strike to get to their flight in time.

We had a quiz you had to answer "correctly" to buy a ticket to Borderland, and I think it was a fun way to highlight some things. It was mostly consent, LNT, and emotional self reliance related.

In the end there's no right way to burn, and we shouldn't force people to read like Hakim Bey before being allowed in. Even worse forcing people to read something a burner has written. No reading should be necessary to participate, be included, and burn.

Participation for some people is spreadsheets and technical drawings many months before, for others letting our neurodiverse brains sparkle on site, others again giving someone who needs it a hug.

Kris

Kris August 26th, 2021 22:12

Just realized I was halfway replying to @RMD with this flying stuff, apologies.

I think there's a real issue to be addressed with your first point and Talk. It's not at all easy to discover or get around in, and it doesn't really get much better with experience. I'm frequently exhausted and give up when faced with walls of more or less well written text (like the one I'm currently producing, it would seem). The other place you can find information is Facebook, and that's even worse. There are some alternative social media that might actually suit the community better.

Kris

Kris August 26th, 2021 22:23

I don't know, most people who can afford the trip could probably also afford a 100 eur to realize some art. I'd much rather fund big things, seeing people do impressive things makes me aspire to do similar things (and apply for that serious art grant). I went to Nest once and was really impressed with what some of the camps were putting up for such a small event, the reason of which I guess is because the same projects go to Nowhere later. Borderland only does this dreams platform thing, and is really not getting much art at the event because only has these small sums (and often the dream can be a tent for a camp, or supplies for a workshop). Burning Man funds big things, and those artists often sell the art later to be permanently displayed somewhere, which I assume BMORG gets a piece of to keep funding artists.

K

Kitt August 26th, 2021 23:36

Gosh I tried to write this in short but I simply cannot speak to each of your sentences concisely. Happy to take this up in real time sometime.

'Most people who can afford the trip could probably also afford a 100 eur to realize some art.'

Firstly, 'most people' is not inclusion, and if those people can afford 100 euro, great! Then for the people who cannot afford 100 euro and have a cool idea, it would be great to support them with an art grant-->more participation, more inclusion, more self expression. You can still have big art grants I am just suggesting a handful of micro art grants as a trial idea for next time, not set in stone forever.

Secondly, 100 euro is a lot of money for some people, and would make the difference between them being able to participate and bring art or not. And I don't think that people not having 100 euro spare should exclude them from coming to the burn, or getting to express themselves with art.

The thing about the regionals often is that you don't need to have hundreds and hundreds of dollars to participate, especially if it's your local burn. Many regionals have 'local' tickets that are discounted, and every burn I've heard of has 'low income' tickets of some kind to help participation, inclusion. I would encourage you to broaden your mind regarding the income levels and lifestyles of the burners that exist.

I understand the drive for incredible large-scale art, but if you're trying to recreate the feeling you felt at a different burn then I don't know what to tell you... a burn is not an art gallery, nor is it only a place for established default world artists to contribute their work. Big art does not make a better or more authentic experience for everyone. I would not want to see more 'big things' at the expense of 'more participants getting to realize art.' If you think there is an artist or an art type you would like to see, either create it yourself or fundraise to enable an artist like that to participate...

Every burn I've read the art-grant system for does it slightly differently. There is not a 'right' or 'wrong' way, but it is something that shapes and is shaped by that regional burn and its participants. Some fund workshops, some don't. Nowhere only funds art outside the camps (eg sculptures) and never structures whereas other burns might help fund materials to build a stage or bar... etc etc. I've never heard of just a 'tent for a camp' getting funded (have you?), and at KB there's no structure that's not publicly accessible that gets funded from art grants.... Also 'supplies for a workshop' no consumables are covered under art grants at KB either...

FWIW I'm not a fan of the dreams platform either. IIRC only 50% of people actually bother to vote, and tbh each individual burner doesn't necessarily know what they want when they read someone's proposal, but that's a whole other conversation.

Burning Nest builds on the camping culture of the UK birthed in events like Glastonbury, and many UK burners don't necessarily go to Spain for Nowhere... I don't know where you got that assumption from. There's loads of small-scale burns in the UK that have a lot of magic to them, and loads of unique camps and installations you'll only find there, especially because they include locals who might not want or be able to travel, for time or resources or age/ability or other responsibilities etc etc. These people are still burners, these events are still burns.

I also have no idea of what BMORG does (what's the decommodification vibes on reselling burner art? or the immediacy of making it a permanent installation?) and honestly it's an event that's 70x the size of this one, on the other side of the world, and exists in a completely different art industry. Why should burner art be permanent, that doesn't make it better or worse in the space of a temporary autonomous zone. I honestly don't think the regionals should necessarily care what Burning Man in the United States does. The principles are largely but not completely the same, but the scale of the event and the different terrain alone should mean there are different things to think about, to keep in mind.

What is unique and amazing about KiezBurn to you, and the burners and art at kiez burn? Would love to hear your thoughts on this. x

Vlad

Vlad August 27th, 2021 05:14

I like the idea of weekend warrior tickets. It would be interesting to know what is actually a percentage of the ppl this year who first came on Friday. What I am thinking is that it will get messy and won't be followed as strictly in the end: I am thinking about this year where half of our camp was delayed by 1-2 days because of the Bahn strike

I did not say material, but a promise of an action is better than just i was on time for ticket sales and had good internet connection. I know ppl this year who were in a important call when ticket sales started and did not get the ticket till the very last moment when squatters were selling their tickets last minute.

I am a firm believer in lotteries, I did not say all tickets should be sold this way, but general sale for a limited amount of tickets should always go through a lottery - it is a fair and effective way to distribute the tickets. It also stimulates ppl who really want to be there to get active so that they get a directed ticket and don't need to participate in the lottery.

Vlad

Vlad August 27th, 2021 05:21

Impressive art is expensive, 100 euro is nothing in current reality - meaning sure it could be a lot of money for someone, but it won't get you far if you want to do something especially on a short time frame.

Kate

Kate September 7th, 2021 11:18

Did you already see this thread? We had a really interesting discussion (and advice process + decision) about this last time as well :) @Saskia (The Fuzzy Facilitator) @Kris @CJ Yetman @Vlad @Lise @RMD @Kitt https://talk.kiezburn.org/d/QaEJ9Fit/-advice-process-kiez-burn-population-growth-